A Kiwanis International Resource Portal
 

Open to Change


 “Organizations that choose to bemoan societal changes are often left behind by new ventures that are proactive and responsive. While it is not easy to be nimble when you are 94 years old, Kiwanis can take steps to position itself for the future.”  (Kiwanis Insider-January 26, 2009)

In the last issue of the Kiwanis Insider we identified some of the changes in society that our organization must respond to if we are to become attractive and magnetic to a next generation of Kiwanis members.  The most significant of those issues relates to the advances in technology that have revolutionized how people communicate with each other.  Our first International President George Hixson (1916-1918) could not possibly have imagined a world where each of his Kiwanis members carried an electronic device that would allow them to talk to one another no matter where they were on the planet.  I imagine George would have thought you had taken leave of your senses if you told him that one day the International President would be able to send a message to 250,000 Kiwanis members in 70 countries in less than five seconds and without a single piece of paper changing hands. 

Early Kiwanis clubs were formed at a time when cars were not reliable enough to drive long distances, when long-distance phone calls were an expensive luxury, and where travel from Europe or Asia to North America most likely involved a very long boat ride.  In most families men were the financial providers, women kept the home and raised the children, and everyone lived in the same community where they worked. 

While the world has changed dramatically over the last ninety years, the structure of Kiwanis remains almost unchanged since the mid 1920’s.  Numerous attempts to suggest structural changes over the years have been met with fierce opposition and have spawned pages of rules primarily designed to protect the status quo.  While everyone understands that not all change is for the better, our Kiwanis history reflects a much stronger commitment to rules and tradition than to flexibility and adaptation.  This is what makes the approval of the “flexible membership initiatives” at the 2006 San Antonio Convention so historic and important.  Through this initiative the delegates have given the leaders of Kiwanis permission to pilot new programs and initiatives that conflict with our current bylaws and policies, but may help us grow.  Several of the initiatives currently being piloted were ones that died on the floor of the House of Delegates in the past. 

As a Kiwanis leader I want to thank you for your willingness to try new ideas to help Kiwanis grow.   I also want to ask for your help in advocating for even more change so that we can reach the next generation of Kiwanis members.  It will not be possible without you. 

So, here is my question.  What are some of the things that you think need to be changed about Kiwanis to make us more attractive to both the current and future generations of Kiwanis members?

 


Posted Feb 17 2009, 08:51 PM by Rob Parker

Comments

Mario S. Grasso wrote re: Open to Change
on 02-18-2009 8:55 AM

When my wife Jo-Ann and I moved to Florida in 1972, the state had a population of about 6 million, today it has a population of about 21 million.

The landscape is forever changing and so have people's attitudes. What was accepted at one time does not have much weight in today's world.

While clubs still need to be local in order to serve and strengthen the local community, state functions should become regional and less rigid in format.

Outlining specifics in this type of format would be counter productive as there are many waiting to play the blame game without offering viable long range alternatives.

Kiwanis is not Amway and should stop acting like an Amway.

John Cano wrote re: Open to Change
on 02-19-2009 4:49 PM

In response to Mr. Grasso:  What is Amway, and precisely what parallel are you trying to draw between Kiwanis and Amway? (Excuse my ignorance, I'm a 21 year old Texan)

I think that the current "brand re-freshening" of Kiwanis is a great start to making people take notice of Kiwanis and understand a clearly defined mission. My concern is those clubs that ignore the the great possibilities and successes that can come from demonstrating a consistent (but not necessarily cloned) image of Kiwanis across the world.

Darrel Both, Past Governor Texas-Oklahoma District wrote re: Open to Change
on 02-22-2009 2:14 PM

I, too, would like to know what Kiwanis and Amway have in common. That is like comparing a horse to a cow. While they both may be animals they certainly serve a much different purpose. With that said, we have been attempting to deal with the changing demographics for some time.Having just returned from our annual midwinter conference I feel we are so far behind the curve that while it may not be impossible to catch up we are going to have to bite the bullet and make some drastic changes. Younger people (potential members) are not being attracted to service organizations because they see old people doing ancient things or some cases nothing but meet, eat, burp and go home. Speaking to several of the attendees at the conference they were asked why they came to these meetings. Answer----to see some of my old friends I have not seen in a while. You can get some of the same answers when asked to why they attend district and International Conventions. The younger generations don't think as we older ones do and we can't make ourselves think as they do. The efforts being made now as to satellite clubs, corporate clubs, etc as Rob Parker spoke of coming out of the San Antonio convention is a step in the right direction. Efforts are being made in our division to form a new club with new ideas and if you are over 50 you probably will not be invited to attend. As the old saying goes--think long, think wrong. Much has to be done but don't let it take too long.

Mario S. Grasso wrote re: Open to Change
on 02-23-2009 3:38 PM

If I had left out that Amway remark I have wondered what the response would have been to what I had previously written. The Amway remark was meant to illustrate Service above Recruitment.

Rob parker is correct in suggesting that change via "flexible membership initives" as outlined in the 2006 San Antonio International Convention was historic.

Satellite clubs may be the answer but when I was young, I'm 67, I probably didn't pay too much attention to traditions.

We have a new club in our District that is mostly young and female and has iniated a late afternoon meeting starting time and meet only twice a month with the Board meeting after the first meeting of the month. They listen and then act.

It is ironic that almost 3 years after that historic convention we are still Talking about new ideas and change.

Shannon Love wrote re: Open to Change
on 02-23-2009 8:14 PM

As a Circle K member, I can tell you one thing I saw that will likely help another organization very similar to Kiwanis. Every month, we do a program in downtown St. Petersburg that is called first night. Local radio stations and such come out. Civitan was there recruiting and showed helping programs like special olympics. They also changed their meeting once a month to include a mixer at a local bar. Though this may not be the traditional format, it was a really good idea, and something to consider.

Mavis Liddie wrote re: Open to Change
on 02-27-2009 10:48 AM

I am a Retired Registered Nurse ,who was very involved with my community through my church  in New York ;eg  promoting Health Fairs and mentoring youths etc .So when Cedric and I came to Deltona he joined the Kiwanis club of Deltona,and I joined later .(I also joined 2 other organization

which no longer exist) I must say that  I have two service

programs in my life....number one to serve my God and Savior Jesus Christ, and to serve my fellowmen/women.

Kiwanis has given me great joy and the opportunity to make a

difference in the life of children .and our community. Yes we do need change that is good ,change that will improve service  to more children, all over the world

that will attract and retain dedicated members young and old to carry on the work .So Lets evaluate our local clubs ,do workshops ,find out what works best ..inform and communicate information up the Kiwanis ladder.

My club President 2008-2009,Jamie Jessup is a dynamic

young man who with Gods help is taking our club to greater

hights....he was a great asset to me during my Presidency,2007-2008. But guess what ? it could not be done without the steadfast ,dedicated ,committed members including our Lt Gov Mario Grasso ;whose ages range from???/ to 80+yrs old and include 2 legion of honor members Last but not least

change is needed , also ,from the top eg antiquated byelaws

I am proud to be a Kiwanian

Cindy Schoppert wrote re: Open to Change
on 03-03-2009 9:05 AM

I think what Kiwanis must do is consider the young professionals within their community, and strategize to accommodate their schedules.  My own particular club meets every Tuesday at noon.  While this may be convenient to the retirees, which our club is primarly made up of, it doesn't address the needs of the younger members who would like to be more involved but can't due to work schedules.  I've fought for many years to get our meeting time changed from afternoon to evening, but to no avail.  It seems the general feeling is "if it ain't broke, don't fix it."  With membership dwindling everywhere, it's time to rethink this.

Jennifer Harris wrote re: Open to Change
on 03-04-2009 2:34 PM

I am a new member in my club. I am only 29 years old. I was never a part of Key Club or Circle K. I got into Kiwanis becuase I now have a family and I remember what the Kiwanis in our area did for me when I was young. I wanted to do that for my kids and for the community. I decided it was my turn.

When I went to join I was lucky enought to have my dad be a member and sponser me. I knew others my age who would be great members, but they see all the "older people" and feel unable or deterred. I mean no disrespect by the older people comment but our group is 70% over the age of 60. I think a change to make the group young and fresh again would be great. Making more pamplets and ideas to help the younger members join and feel needed with help with man power and energy, which in turn will help the service of each group.

Jennifer Harris wrote re: Open to Change
on 03-04-2009 2:43 PM

Cindy Schoppert- Our group meets on Wednesday NIGHT at 7pm. Our dinner starts at 6:30. We find it works better for those who are not retired and for the moms who are stay at home to find someone to watch the kids. Our group too is a " don't fix it if it isn't broke." Try putting a questionaire together and see how many people want it changed. Have a space for club improvment ideas. Spend one meeting on club imporovment and growth. Sometimes it takes one of us to speak up and say if we are not growing and changing then we are dying. We have to stay relevant to the times. Some things that worked 10 years ago are not going to do now.

I know if you say that in our group some may not like it, but for the group as a whole sometimes we need to step out and gently but passionatly make a change.

Add a Comment

(required)  
(optional)
(required)  
Remember Me?
Copyright © 2007 Kiwanis International. All Rights Reserved. Web design by www.danfinney.com